🇺🇸 New York City vs 🇺🇸 Key West
Weather Comparison
Current Weather Right Now
🇺🇸
New York City
41°F
Clear Sky
Feels like 34°F
H 44°F / L 40°F
Humidity: 28%
🇺🇸
Key West
84°F
Light Rain
Feels like 87°F
H 84°F / L 80°F
Humidity: 55%
Climate Overview
New York City
Humid continental — hot summers, cold winters, year-round precipitation
New York City has four distinct seasons. Fall is the sweet spot: mild temps, low humidity, and the city at peak energy. Summers are hot and muggy; winters bring snow and bitter wind chill, especially near the waterfront.
Key West
Key West at America's southernmost point has a true tropical climate — the only place in the continental US where it genuinely never gets cold. Surrounded by water on all sides, temperatures are moderated dramatically with winters in the 70s and summers rarely above 92°F. Hurricane risk is severe, and the Florida Straits can generate massive swells.
Seasonal Comparison
| Season | 🇺🇸 New York City | 🇺🇸 Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Spring | 42–68°F March–May | — |
| Summer | 72–88°F June–August | — |
| Fall | 50–72°F September–November | — |
| Winter | 26–40°F December–February | — |
New York City vs Key West: Frequently Asked Questions
Does New York City or Key West have better weather?
New York City and Key West have very different climates. Humid continental — hot summers, cold winters, year-round precipitation Key West: Key West at America's southernmost point has a true tropical climate — the only place in the contine. The best city depends on your preferred season and temperature range.
When is the best time to visit New York City vs Key West?
Best time for New York City: September, October, May, June. Best time for Key West: spring and fall.